- Morningstar flags 33 U.S. stocks trading below its fair-value estimates, with five-star names implying the market is overly pessimistic and offering the best risk/reward.
- Discounts are concentrated in small-value plus communication services, consumer cyclical, real estate, energy, and parts of tech, while many defensive sectors sit near or above fair value.
- Ten five-star picks—BBWI, UA, CPB, KHC, CMCSA, MDLZ, BA, KMX, COLD, and DOC—trade at roughly 0.40–0.77 of fair value (about 23–60% discounts).
- The thesis favors diversified, wide-moat value exposure as rates/sentiment normalize, but hinges on fair-value accuracy and resilience amid ongoing macro and competitive risks.
Read More
Morningstar’s latest analysis surfaces meaningful opportunities for value investors. Its metric “price/fair-value ratio” shows many stocks — especially in certain sectors — trading significantly below what Morningstar’s model deems intrinsic value. Stocks rated five stars are defined as those where the market is “excessively pessimistic,” offering greater upside with constrained downside. Sectors where distortions appear largest: communications, consumer cyclicals, real estate, energy, and particularly small-value names.
From the group of 33 undervalued stocks, a subset of ten five-star stocks stands out: names like BBWI, UA, CPB, KHC, CMCSA, MDLZ, BA, KMX, COLD, and DOC with price/fair value ratios ranging from ~0.40 to 0.77. A ratio of 1.0 implies fair value; thus, many are discounted heavily (~23-60%) indicating compelling entry points for long-term investors willing to bear some uncertainty.
Sector-level trends show divergence:
- Small-value stocks are trading ~23–40% below fair value depending on region/timeframe.
- Real estate sector is among the most undervalued at ~10-12% discount. Stocks with defensive characteristics (healthcare real estate, wireless towers, retail) are preferred.
- Technology and communications are now also in discount territory following fair value upward revisions combined with recent weakness. Mega-caps with wide economic moats (e.g., Alphabet, Microsoft, etc.) are among these.
However, not all sectors are ripe. Consumer defensive, utilities, industrials, financial services are largely at fair value or overvalued. Overweighting undervalued names in traditionally defensive sectors may lead to underperformance if economic shocks persist.
Looking ahead, a few strategic implications emerge for institutional and high net-worth investors:
- Margin of safety is strongest in deeply discounted five-star names; patience and capital income (dividend yield) should be part of selection criteria.
- Wide-moat businesses will likely outperform if market sentiment improves, particularly with interest rate easing or certainty in central bank policy.
- Diversification across sectors is critical — betting heavily in small-value or real estate could expose portfolios to sector-specific risks.
Open questions:
- How soon will macro headwinds (inflation, rates, policy risk) reverse enough to unlock valuation compression?
- Are the fair value estimates properly accounting for long-term shifts (e.g. AI, energy transitions, ESG)?
- How durable are the wide moats? Do regulatory or competitive risks threaten them?
Supporting Notes
- Morningstar defines undervalued stocks as those trading below its fair-value estimates, adjusted for uncertainty; five-star stocks indicate “excessively pessimistic outlook” and superior risk/reward.
- The list includes 10 US five-star rated names: CMCSA (~0.68), BBWI (~0.42), UA (~0.40), CPB (~0.44), KHC (~0.46), MDLZ (~0.75), BA (~0.77), KMX (~0.46), COLD (~0.51), DOC (~0.61) price-to-fair-value ratios.
- Small-value stocks are trading ~23% below fair value as of start of 2026.
- Real estate is the most undervalued sector, trading at ~12% discount; other sectors like energy and technology follow at ~9–10% discounts.
- Defensive sectors (consumer defensive, utilities, financials, industrials) remain overvalued or near fair value.
- Wide-moat businesses are emphasized (e.g. in real estate with DOC, or sector-leaders like Microsoft, Alphabet) as likely to sustain competitive advantage and profits.
- Fair value revisions: Massive increases in Morningstar’s intrinsic valuations for mega-cap tech (Alphabet +$2.5T, Nvidia +$1.2T, Broadcom +$740B, Apple +$440B) in Q4 2025 pushed overall valuation metrics downwards, creating new discounts.